Wal-Mart: Working to elect Democrats?
A couple weeks ago, Wal-Mart announced that -- in addition to expanding its Blue Light Special empire into China (where, unlike U.S. employees, Wal-Mart workers will have unions) -- it is launching a drive to register 1.3 million of its "associates" to vote.As Daniel Gross points out at Slate, it wouldn't be a stretch to doubt the motives of the Bentonville, Ark. retail goliath's experiment in civic engagement: Critics will assume that this is yet another attempt by Wal-Mart to stack the deck in favor of its favorite political party: the GOP. As the Center for Responsive Politics noted, Wal-Mart has given more than $1 million in federal campaign donations in this cycle, with 71 percent going to Republicans. And Wal-Mart itself is a lot like the contemporary Republican Party—strong in the South, Midwest, Sunbelt, and Great Plains, weak in the cities and coastal areas, and steadfastly hostile to organized labor.But whatever Wal-Mart's intentions, the fact is that the company's employees aren't the GOP base -- they look a lot more like Democrats: Wal-Mart's diversity data shows that the company's workforce, and in particular its vast army of sales associates, looks an awful lot like the Democratic base. It is disproportionately African-American. African-Americans are about 11 percent of the American population and vote overwhelmingly for Democrats. According to this CNN exit poll, they went for Kerry by an 88-11 margin in 2004. But African-Americans constitute nearly 17 percent of Wal-Mart's employees and 18 percent of sales workers. Encouraging more middle- and lower-income African-Americans to vote in states like Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Mississippi would almost certainly be a net positive for Democratic candidates.For those who think Wal-Mart's plan is to ultimately turn these reliably Democratic constituencies into GOP voters, Gross points out that this will be a tall order. More likely is that Wal-Mart workers will tend to vote "the way other African-American, female, and low-wage workers who toil elsewhere tend to vote" -- Democratic.And even if Wal-Mart does use some of the same arm-twisting tactics to influence voters that it uses with prospective union members -- from "captive meetings" to more subtle techniques -- the long-term impact will be limited. Every year, 40% of Wal-Mart employees quit their jobs anyway. But they'll still be registered voters.UPDATE: Two new battles brewing at Wal-Mart: 200 employees walking off the job in Hialeah Gardens, Fla., calling new restrictive employee policies "inhuman," and Mexican leaders investigating the company's alleged meddling in their recent presidential elections.
Tags
Chris Kromm
Chris Kromm is executive director of the Institute for Southern Studies and publisher of the Institute's online magazine, Facing South.